| Friday, May 17, 2002
- WASHINGTON - The Bush administration has decided not to use
substandard steel drums, which could rupture in a crash, to haul
plutonium from Rocky Flats to California and South Carolina.
U.S. Department of Energy officials announced Thursday they will
use only containers that can pass a "dynamic crush test" to
transport nuclear materials from the former nuclear weapons plant 13
miles northwest of Denver. They decided not to invoke a "national
security exemption" allowing them to use larger, weaker containers,
called DT-22s.
The DT-22 container, according to its designer, will not pass a
crush test in which a 1,100-pound weight is dropped on it from 30
feet, simulating a high-speed crash.
Use of the containers had been challenged in lawsuits by South
Carolina Gov. Jim Hodges seeking to block shipments to the Savannah
River Site near Aiken, S.C., and by activist neighbors of the
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory near San Francisco.
"We want to move forward, rather than engage in unnecessary and
costly litigation from environmental groups that could delay the
environmental restoration of our Rocky Flats facility," Assistant
Energy Secretary Jessie Roberson said in a statement.
Department of Energy engineers had raised numerous objections to
using the weaker containers, according to e-mails obtained by the
California activists through a Freedom of Information Act request.
The engineers said the exemption was not for national security, but
to cut costs and meet the politically popular 2006 deadline, despite
mistakes by the department and the cleanup contractor, Kaiser-Hill.
But political appointees in the Clinton administration granted the
exemption anyway.
"If an SST (truck carrying nuclear material) was hit by a train,
the crush environment would occur," one engineer wrote. "If an SST
was hit from behind by a large, heavy vehicle, the crush environment
may occur."
Energy officials will have to cut some classified nuclear weapons
pieces down to size to fit into the smaller containers, which are
about the size of two office trash cans stacked on top of each
other. Those who supported using the DT-22s, which are 45-gallon
drums, said cutting the pieces up would increase risks to workers at
the plant and cost up to $100 million more. DOE spokesman Joe Davis
did not return a telephone call for comment Thursday.
Rocky Flats produced explosive plutonium "triggers" for 40 years
until 1989. The federal government is spending $7 billion to turn it
into a wildlife refuge.
DOE officials say shipments must begin soon to meet the 2006
cleanup deadline. But they've been delayed until at least June 15 by
Hodges' lawsuit.
A DOE report issued Thursday indicated that Hodges might not be
the only delay. A new Energy Department report says that Rocky Flats
is behind schedule in getting containers filled and ready for
shipment.
The packaging was supposed to be done by the end of this month,
but the DOE inspector general says that only about half the 1,900
containers will be ready by then. They are expected to be finished
by early next year.
"Missed milestones increase the risk of delays to the planned
2006 Rocky Flats closure date," wrote Inspector General Gregory
Friedman, "which has significant cost implications for the
department's environmental remediation effort."
Kaiser-Hill Co., the contractor doing the cleanup at Rocky Flats,
says the plant will be cleaned up and closed by Dec. 15, 2006.
Company spokesman John Corsi said the packaging machine did not work
well early on, but is now in working order.
"The rates have varied, but we're confident with the rate we're
at now," Corsi said. "It's not going to impact 2006."
|